Skip to main content
Back to Steel City Stories
The Day Pittsburgh Swallowed an Entire City — Steel City Stories
HistoryChapter 35 of 4117 min read

The Day Pittsburgh Swallowed an Entire City

Steel City Stories

Preparing the first passage.

Steel City Stories · Chapter 35

Allegheny City was not a neighborhood that Pittsburgh gradually absorbed. It was a city, with a mayor, councils, debts, a water system, a library, and, at the Twelfth Census, a population of 129,896. In 1907 it ceased to be a city and became Pittsburgh’s North Side. The houses did not move. The Allegheny River did not move. The government disappeared, and the lawsuit that tried to save it became a national rule about how little the federal Constitution would do to stop a state from redrawing a municipal map. The rule is real. It is also narrower than the slogan that later writers sometimes make of it. This chapter stays with the statute, the vote, the census, and the opinion the Supreme Court actually filed.

The census figure is not a rounding. Bulletin and volume tables of the 1900 census list Allegheny, Pennsylvania, among the country’s large cities, and the 1910 census abstract for Pennsylvania, explaining Pittsburgh’s new total, carries Allegheny City’s 1900 population forward as 129,896 and its 1890 population as 105,287. The same 1900 count gives Pittsburgh 321,616. In the consolidation case itself, the objectors pleaded those census numbers — 129,896 for Allegheny and 321,616 for Pittsburgh — as facts about the two cities. No one in the litigation treated Allegheny as a village being tidied into a metropolis. It was, on the census the courts were shown, a city of the scale of a major American municipality, set against a larger neighbor across the river. Size is why the voting rule mattered. A smaller city that must win a separate majority can veto a merger. A smaller city whose ballots are poured into a combined pile cannot.

The statute counted all the votes together

The law that did the pouring was the Pennsylvania act of February 7, 1906, passed at a special session the governor had called. The November 11, 1905 proclamation summoned the General Assembly for January 15, 1906, and the first subject on the call was legislation to let contiguous cities in the same county unite so that people might avoid the cost of duplicate governments. A January 9, 1906 addition widened the subject to cities contiguous or in close proximity, including intervening land. The statute that emerged, 1906 Public Laws 7, is titled as an act to enable such cities to unite, with intervening land other than boroughs, and to sort out debts and temporary government. Section 1, as the United States Supreme Court later quoted it, provides that two cities contiguous or in close proximity, with any intervening land other than boroughs, may be united by annexing the lesser city to the greater, if at an election there is a majority of all the votes cast in favor of the union.

The phrase “all the votes cast” is the mechanism. Section 7, again as the Supreme Court set it out, tells the court of quarter sessions to decree the annexation if a majority of all the lawful voters of the two cities and the intervening land, voting on the question, have voted in favor. It does not say a majority in each city. It does not give the lesser city a separate veto. Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court, in Pittsburg’s Petition, upheld that structure against the charge that the act was forbidden local or special legislation. The court stressed that the act was written for any two cities meeting the geographic conditions, not as a statute that named Pittsburgh and Allegheny. It distinguished an earlier “Cook Law,” struck down because that law’s contiguity rules, including a clause about cities separated by a river, effectively described only these two places. The 1906 act survived, in the state court’s view, because its class was general even though the first and most important pair it could catch was the pair on the Allegheny River.

Objectors also attacked the special session itself, arguing that the governor’s original call had not fairly included the bill that passed. The state supreme court refused to manage the governor’s proclamations as if they were flawed pleadings. It treated the January 9 notice as a real second call and declined to invalidate the act for the way the extra subjects were added. Those holdings are state constitutional law. They explain why the fight that remained, when the case reached Washington, was a federal fight about due process, contract, and property, not a fight about whether the General Assembly had used the wrong session. By then the election had already happened, and the numbers were on the record.

Allegheny voted no, and lost anyway

Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court stated the election result as a majority of 20,154 in favor of consolidation, out of a total vote in the two cities of 55,574. On June 16, 1906, the quarter sessions of Allegheny County decreed that Allegheny, the lesser city, be annexed to Pittsburgh so that they form one city in Pittsburgh’s name. The United States Supreme Court then recorded the fact that decides the moral shape of the story, and recorded it as agreed rather than as a rumor: a majority of the voters of Allegheny voted against consolidation, and that majority was overcome by a larger majority in Pittsburgh. The combined pile produced the overall majority the statute required. Allegheny’s rejection was real. It was not a veto. Anyone who writes that “Allegheny voted to join Pittsburgh” is rewriting the agreed fact. Anyone who writes that the merger happened with no vote at all is rewriting the statute. The accurate sentence is the uncomfortable one. There was an election. The smaller city lost it under a rule that counted the larger city’s ballots in the same column.

The objectors tried to make that rule a federal wrong. Their exceptions, which the Supreme Court quoted at length, said Allegheny’s 1900 population was 129,896 and Pittsburgh’s 321,616, and they estimated the current populations higher, with roughly 24,000 votes cast in Allegheny’s last mayoral election and roughly 62,000 in Pittsburgh’s, both on February 20, 1906. They argued that letting the larger electorate overpower the smaller one forced a union without Allegheny’s consent. The Court did not deny the description. It denied that the federal Constitution forbade it. Justice William Moody’s opinion, decided November 18, 1907, after argument on October 25 and 28, said the precise question had not been determined before and was not so thin that the Court could brush it aside. Then the Court brushed aside the hope that a city’s voters hold a federal right to their city’s continued existence.

What Hunter decided, and what it refused to decide

Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh, 207 U.S. 161, is the name the case took from D. Hunter Jr. and the other plaintiffs in error, who were joined by the City of Allegheny itself after the Superior Court let the city intervene. The opinion’s core is a doctrine about municipal corporations, and it should be quoted in substance rather than inflated. Municipal corporations, the Court said, are political subdivisions of the state, created as convenient agencies for exercising governmental powers the state entrusts to them. The number, nature, and duration of their powers, and the territory over which those powers run, rest in the state’s discretion. Charters and laws that confer governmental powers, or that vest property to be used for governmental purposes, are not contracts with the state under the federal contract clause. The state may modify or withdraw such powers, take property held for governmental purposes without compensation, hold it or vest it elsewhere, expand or contract the territory, unite the whole or a part with another municipality, and repeal the charter. It may do these things conditionally or unconditionally, with or without the citizens’ consent, even against their protest. In all these respects, the Court said, the state is supreme, and its legislature, conforming to the state constitution, is unrestrained by any provision of the Constitution of the United States. Inconvenience, and a decline in property values from higher taxes or any other reason, do not give inhabitants a federal right to the unaltered corporation. If the exercise is unjust, the Court said, the remedy is with those who legislate for the state.

That is a broad holding about political subdivisions, boundaries, governmental powers, and governmental property, inside the federal questions the record presented. It is not a holding that every asset a city owns, in every capacity, may be seized without compensation. The Court said so. It noted that its description of absolute power had not been extended beyond property held and used for governmental purposes. Municipalities sometimes hold property for the same purposes private owners do. The distinction between governmental property and private or proprietary property, the Court wrote, is difficult and had been recognized in many state courts, where legislatures were held not to be omnipotent over the private class. Counsel for the plaintiffs asserted that Allegheny owned property in its private and proprietary capacity and that the annexation took that property without compensation, vesting it in another corporation, in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Court refused to decide that assertion. No such question was presented by the record. There was only a vague suggestion of facts on which it might have been founded. The sixth exception recited Allegheny’s streets, its electric lighting, and its water supply in order to argue about taxes, and the Court said that recital fell far short of a statement that the city held any property in a private and proprietary capacity. There was no allegation that Allegheny had been deprived of its property without due process. The due-process allegation on the record was that taxpayers would be hurt by higher taxes, which the Court called an entirely different proposition. Allegheny’s intervention in the Superior Court added no new allegations. State-court opinions had not considered the private-property question, and the assignments of error in Washington had not raised it. The question, Moody wrote, was entirely outside the record. The Court was without jurisdiction to consider it, and it would neither express nor intimate an opinion upon it.

The difference between those two passages is the difference between a real precedent and a myth. Hunter holds that, on the federal questions presented, Pennsylvania could consolidate these cities under the 1906 act even though Allegheny’s voters said no, and that residents and taxpayers had no federal constitutional shield against the resulting taxes, boundaries, and governmental rearrangement. Hunter does not hold that a city’s proprietary property may be confiscated at will. It holds that this case did not present that question. Later advocates who want the broader sentence have to build it somewhere else. They cannot lift it from a paragraph the Court used to explain what it was not deciding.

The year the city ended

The quarter sessions decree is dated June 16, 1906. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed the state-law challenge in 1907. The United States Supreme Court affirmed on November 18, 1907. The year in which Allegheny City ended and the North Side began, as a completed municipal fact, is 1907. This chapter states that year and does not assign a day. A decision date is not automatically the morning the clerks changed the letterhead, and a local memory of a last meeting is not, without a record this chapter is willing to treat as settled, a reason to print a calendar date and call it the annexation. What the law reports settle is the sequence: a 1906 statute, an election lost by Allegheny voters under a combined count, a 1906 trial-court decree, appeals, and a 1907 federal affirmance after which the former city was Pittsburgh’s North Side.

The human content of that sequence is easy to underwrite because the doctrine is so stark. Allegheny had built institutions that assumed tomorrow would still be Allegheny. The Carnegie Free Library of Allegheny, opened in 1890, is one public marker of a city that took itself seriously enough to accept a library gift on its own legal authority, before Pittsburgh could. The objectors pleaded a satisfactory water supply and a municipal electric system, and they pleaded Pittsburgh’s debts and its plans for the Hump, a filtration plant, and the purchase of a private water company, as reasons their taxes would rise. The Supreme Court noted that no evidence was taken on the factual exceptions and that no decision was made on those factual issues. So this chapter will not adopt the objectors’ comparison of the two water systems as a found fact. It will adopt their fear as the fear the pleadings record: consolidation meant taking on the larger city’s obligations, and the people who had paid for Allegheny’s own works did not consent. The Court answered that fear by saying the federal Constitution was the wrong place to bring it.

A government can vanish without a moving van

No one had to relocate a house for the map to change. Section 9 of the act, as the Court quoted it, preserved the rights of citizens of both cities in the enlarged city, and it preserved creditors’ rights by treating the constituent cities as continuing in law for the enforcement of claims. Another provision vested property of either city in the consolidated city, and authorized commissioners to sort floating and bonded debt and property accounts. Those are the accountant’s version of a conquest. The identity that was lost was corporate and political: ordinances, councils, the name on the tax bill, the ability to refuse a merger at the ballot box. The identity that continued was physical and personal. People woke up in the same rooms, on streets that had been Allegheny streets, inside a city whose name was Pittsburgh. The North Side is that continuity. It is also the reminder, every time a person says “North Side” instead of “Allegheny,” that the losing city kept a geography and lost the noun.

Hunter’s afterlife is larger than the North Side, which is why the holding has to stay accurate. Courts and legislatures have cited it for the proposition that municipalities are creatures of the state and that residents have no federal right to freeze a charter or a boundary. That citation is faithful when it stays with governmental powers, territory, and consent. It becomes an overstatement when it is used as a blanket permission slip for taking proprietary assets without compensation, the question Moody set outside the case. Pittsburgh gained a population that the 1900 census had counted at 129,896 in the city across the river, and it gained the land, the debts, and the litigation that went with them. Allegheny’s voters gained a precedent that explains why their majority was not enough. They did not gain a reversal. The state had written a counting rule that made Pittsburgh’s larger “yes” decisive, the state courts had upheld the rule, and the nation’s highest court had said the federal Constitution did not stand in the way.

How a petition became a combined election

The statute’s middle sections, as the United States Reports print them, show that the combined majority was not an accident of ballot design. Either city’s councils could, by ordinance, direct that a petition be filed in the court of quarter sessions, or two percent of the registered voters of either city could petition, asking that the two cities and any intervening land other than boroughs be united. The court fixed a hearing, gave notice to the mayors and to the clerks of councils, and published in the newspapers. Any interested person could file exceptions. If the court found the petition regular, it ordered an election in both cities, and every legal voter of either city, and of the intervening land, was qualified to vote. The count that followed was not two counts with two vetoes. Section 7 told the quarter sessions to enter the decree of annexation if a majority of all the lawful voters of the two cities and the intervening land, voting on the question, favored it, the lesser city folding into the greater city’s name. Pittsburgh filed the petition. The objectors filed exceptions. The court dismissed the exceptions without taking evidence on the factual disputes, ordered the election, and later entered the decree the state supreme court dated June 16, 1906. The procedure was public, judicial, and stacked by the rule of the combined pile.

That stack is why the population figures are not color. A city of 129,896 facing a city of 321,616, on the 1900 census both the pleadings and the census volumes carry, is a city that can win every one of its own wards and still lose if the statute adds the ballots together. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s combined total — 55,574 votes, a majority of 20,154 in favor — is the arithmetic of that rule, not a claim that Allegheny’s opposition was small. The United States Supreme Court stated the opposition as an agreed fact: Allegheny’s voters produced a majority against consolidation, and Pittsburgh’s larger majority overcame it. The federal answer was that a state’s legislature may arrange municipalities against the protest of the people inside them, so long as the legislature stays within the state constitution and the federal question actually presented is the one Hunter decided. Consent, in this doctrine, is not a federal prerequisite for the death of a city.

What the objectors put on paper, and what no one proved

The exceptions are a portrait of a city arguing for its life in the language of taxes and improvements. The objectors said they were residents, voters, taxpayers, and owners of property in Allegheny. They recited streets, electric lighting, and a water supply they called satisfactory, and they recited Pittsburgh’s debts, parks, boulevards, reservoirs, the cutting of the Hump on Fifth Avenue, a filtration plant, the contemplated purchase of the Monongahela Water Company’s plant, and an electric plant Pittsburgh did not yet own. They said annexation would add taxes, depreciate their property, and take it without due process, invoking the Fifth Amendment and then the Fourteenth. The Supreme Court treated the Fifth Amendment claim as a nonstarter against a state, and it treated the contract claim — an implied promise that Allegheny’s taxpayers would be taxed only for Allegheny — as contrary to the nature of a municipal corporation. It treated the due-process claim that was actually pleaded, the claim about higher taxes, as within its jurisdiction and as losing under the subdivision doctrine. It treated the different claim, about proprietary city property, as not pleaded and therefore not decided.

The factual comparison of the two cities’ utilities was never tried. The opinion says no evidence was introduced on the exceptions and no decision was made on those issues of fact. A later writer who “knows” that Allegheny’s water was better, because the exception says so, is reading a brief as a finding. This chapter will not. The fear in the brief is still historical evidence of what consolidation meant to the people who filed it: a larger city’s spending, folded onto a smaller city’s taxpayers, under a vote the smaller city had lost. Section 9’s promise that creditors would be protected and that citizens of both cities would be citizens of the enlarged city is the statute’s answer to identity. You keep your debts and you lose your city. The North Side is the geographic name for that bargain after 1907.

Hunter’s restraint about proprietary property is the part of the opinion most often dropped when the case is used as a slogan, so it is worth saying again in the language of jurisdiction rather than of sympathy. Counsel asserted a taking of Allegheny’s private-capacity property. The Court said the record did not present the question, that the only property recital was a tax argument about streets, lights, and water, and that Allegheny’s late intervention added no new facts. It cited its own limits and stopped. A reader who needs the Court to have authorized every future seizure of municipal property will not find the authorization in that stop. A reader who needs the Court to have saved Allegheny City will not find the rescue in the holding it did make. The holding it made is that a municipal corporation is a political subdivision, that the state may alter its powers and its boundaries, and that the federal questions actually before the Court did not forbid this consolidation. Within those questions the state was supreme. Outside them the Court declined to speak. The North Side exists because the questions that were presented were answered against Allegheny, in 1907.

Population makes the loss concrete without inventing a street scene. The 1900 census counted 129,896 people in Allegheny and 321,616 in Pittsburgh. Adding those communities under one government was not a boundary tidy-up at the edge of a town. It was the end of a municipal corporation large enough to rank among the country’s major cities, accomplished by a statute that required only a majority of all votes cast across the combined territory. Allegheny’s voters supplied a majority against that end. Pittsburgh’s voters supplied a larger majority for it. The state courts upheld the counting rule. The United States Supreme Court affirmed in 1907 and left the unpresented proprietary-property question undecided. The former city became the North Side in 1907. The river stayed. The councils did not. What Pittsburgh swallowed was a government, a census population of 129,896, and a lawsuit that still teaches how far a state may go when the federal questions before the Court are the ones Hunter actually decided. The opinion affirmed the consolidation. It did not decide the proprietary-property question the record never put before it. That limit is part of the holding, and the North Side does not erase it. The year of the completed annexation remains 1907, with no day assigned.

What remains disputed

The calendar day in 1907 when municipal government practically changed hands is disputed in secondary tellings, and this chapter leaves the day unstated. The year is 1907. Estimates of 1906 population in the objectors’ pleadings — “at least 350,000” for Pittsburgh and “probably about 150,000” for Allegheny — were pleading estimates, and the Court noted that factual exceptions were not tried. The 129,896 and 321,616 figures are the 1900 census counts, not a count of the election-year population. The majority of 20,154 out of 55,574 is the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s statement of the combined result; it is a margin and a total, not a ward-by-ward canvass reproduced here. How much of Allegheny’s property was governmental and how much was proprietary was exactly the question the United States Supreme Court said the record did not present, so any later inventory that tries to answer it is a different case. Whether the 1906 act was wise, as distinct from whether it was constitutional, is a political judgment the Court assigned to the legislature. The North Side’s subsequent history, including the renewal fights on Manchester and Chateau, belongs to later chapters. It does not change the 1907 fact that an entire city government was ended by a combined vote and a federal affirmance.

Evidence Ledger

This chapter is an original public expansion of PittsburghEverything’s Steel City Stories. It does not replace a Google Drive FULL MASTER.

Archival photographs relevant to this chapter. Sourced from Wikimedia Commons with attribution — not modern stock art.

Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North & Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh (Allegheny County, Pennsylvania)

Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North & Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh (Allegheny County, Pennsylvania)

Wikimedia Commons · Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North & Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh (Allegheny County, Pennsylvania).jpg · Jack Boucher · Public domain

- Allegheny Lift Lock No. 4 and Weigh Lock, North shore of Allegheny River, 0.25 mile Northeast of Ninth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, PA

- Allegheny Lift Lock No. 4 and Weigh Lock, North shore of Allegheny River, 0.25 mile Northeast of Ninth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, PA

Wikimedia Commons · Allegheny Lift Lock No. 4 and Weigh Lock, North shore of Allegheny River, 0.25 mile Northeast of Ninth Street Bridge, Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, PA HAER PA,2-PITBU,63-4.tif · Unknown · Public domain

Historic American Buildings Survey, April, 1963 SOUTH (REAR) AND WEST (SIDE) OVER-ALL. - Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North and Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, PA

Historic American Buildings Survey, April, 1963 SOUTH (REAR) AND WEST (SIDE) OVER-ALL. - Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North and Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, PA

Wikimedia Commons · Historic American Buildings Survey, April, 1963 SOUTH (REAR) AND WEST (SIDE) OVER-ALL. - Emmanuel Protestant Episcopal Church, North and Allegheny Streets, Pittsburgh, Allegheny HABS PA,2-PITBU,18-1.tif · Jack Boucher · Public domain

Related Stories