Skip to main content
Back to Steel City Stories
The Neighborhood Pittsburgh Almost Erased—and the People Who Fought Back — Steel City Stories
HistoryChapter 34 of 4117 min read

The Neighborhood Pittsburgh Almost Erased—and the People Who Fought Back

Steel City Stories

Preparing the first passage.

Steel City Stories · Chapter 34

Manchester and Chateau are the proof that urban renewal was a choice, because they shared a river, a century of building, and a redevelopment map, and they did not share a fate. One side of the later highway kept a grid of brick houses that the city eventually designated as historic. The other side was cleared of homes and businesses and reused for warehouses, light industry, and the road itself. The difference was not geology. It was a fight over whether the existing neighborhood was an obstacle to modernization or the asset modernization was about to throw away. The people who fought did not start with the city’s power. They started with the houses and with organizations that learned how to use preservation law and urban-renewal money against the usual direction of that money.

The city’s own archives describe the scale of the original project without sentiment. A photograph series of Redevelopment Area No. 11 holds 111 images of 164 acres straddling what are now Manchester and Chateau. The City Planning Commission certified the project area on July 14, 1959. The land was redeveloped for commercial and industrial sites, and the street pattern was revamped to extend Ohio River Boulevard. Certification in 1959 is the date that matters for intent. This was not a wartime emergency and not a private landlord’s whim. It was a planned public area, drawn across both neighborhoods, aimed at industry and a boulevard. What happened after certification is the divergence the chapter has to keep in view. A single certified area produced clearance on one side of the story and a preservation district on the other.

What the highway took, and what it walled off

A 2022 Urban Redevelopment Authority study of a Manchester-Chateau tax-increment proposal states the Chateau outcome in one blunt sequence. After the highway was built, more than 700 families and businesses in Chateau were removed and replaced with warehouses, light industry, shipping, and institutional uses. The study’s consequence clause is geographic and racial at once, and it is descriptive rather than a theory of blame: a neighborhood with a history as a home to African American residents on the east side of the highway was walled off from the riverfront and from the economic activity that replaced the old blocks. The highway in question is Pennsylvania Route 65, which a Manchester Citizens Corporation planning narrative describes as a limited-access freeway only for the roughly three miles inside Pittsburgh, from Interstate 279 to the McKees Rocks Bridge. PennDOT figures cited there put average daily traffic on that city segment between 7,619 and 13,283 vehicles, depending on the piece of road. Those volumes are a present-day count, not a 1960s count. They matter because they describe a road that functions as a regional pipe through a neighborhood, not as a local street that replaced the local street in kind.

The same citizens’ narrative supplies the before. Manchester and Chateau grew along the Ohio because the waterfront suited business, and the people who owned those businesses lived in the neighborhood, producing what the narrative calls a diverse middle class. Development followed Ferry Street, later Beaver Avenue, a commercial spine until its demolition. Victorian houses, many of them still standing, went up in the second half of the nineteenth century. Streetcars ran on Ferry Street and on Ohio Lane, later Pennsylvania Avenue. The grid was regular, broken mainly by the Pennsylvania Railroad, until Route 65 cut a second, harder line. Population fell after the Second World War, as it did in much of the city, but the narrative dates the massive and rapid disinvestment to the highway’s construction rather than to the postwar years alone. That distinction is the chapter’s guardrail. Decline is not the same fact as clearance. A neighborhood can lose people slowly and still be a neighborhood. Clearance removes the streets the remaining people would have used.

Walk scores in that planning document are a contemporary measure of what the cut left behind: 45 for the Manchester-Chateau ZIP code, 73 for Allegheny West next door, 62 for the city. A flat, gridded area scoring like a hard place to walk is a design outcome. The narrative counts Manchester’s connections as few: four along the east edge, three along the south, two along the west. Bus service inherited a streetcar geography and then lost the connected grid that had made the streetcars intelligible. None of this required anyone to dislike the residents. It required a priority — move regional traffic, make industrial parcels, extend the boulevard — that treated the old blocks as the land under the priority. The 700 removals are what that priority cost in households and firms, on the authority’s later accounting. The warehouses are what the priority bought.

Liverpool Street and the decision to restore

The Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation dates its own birth to 1964, when Liverpool Street in Manchester and other North Side areas were set to be demolished. The foundation and residents began what it calls the Manchester Program, described as the first of its kind in the United States for low-income and minority families, using federal, state, and local funds to restore a neighborhood that would remain affordable to the people living in it. The foundation’s further claims are specific and should be carried as its claims: the first historic preservation district in the nation created primarily for African Americans; the first preservation program to use Title I urban-renewal funds to restore houses for low- and moderate-income residents; and a set of incentives meant to fight displacement and keep longtime residents in place. “First in the nation” is an institutional superlative. This chapter reports it as the foundation’s account of its own program, not as a finding independently adjudicated here. What does not depend on the superlative is the sequence. Demolition was scheduled. Residents and a new preservation group organized against it. Money that urban renewal usually spent on clearance was steered, in this program, toward repair.

The legal designations came later, which is a reminder that a fight precedes a plaque. The Manchester Historic District was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1975 and designated a city historic district in 1979. The city’s historic-preservation page describes it as Pittsburgh’s largest historic district, 51.6 acres, with more than 600 resources, a neighborhood of brick houses, stone trim, and wooden porches on an orderly grid. Those 600 resources are the physical residue of the argument. They are not evidence that the system protected them automatically. The foundation is explicit that the program had to be built, and that it continues with the Manchester Citizens Corporation. A district on the National Register can still be a poor neighborhood. The point of the Manchester program, as the foundation states it, was not to create a museum for outsiders. It was to make restoration economically possible for the residents who were already there, including low-income and minority families who were usually the people renewal displaced.

That purpose distinguishes Manchester from a later fashion for old houses. Preservation can be a tool of displacement when it raises values and offers no way for tenants and modest owners to stay. The foundation’s description of incentive programs aimed at the opposite: combat displacement, encourage longtime residents to remain, use public restoration money for people of modest income. Whether every incentive worked is a question the celebratory page does not settle with a displacement table. The existence of the aim matters because it shows the organizers understood the danger. They were not naive about what a newly desirable brick street can do to the people who saved it. They tried to write affordability into the preservation itself. Chateau, on the other side of the highway, did not receive that experiment. It received removal and a land-use conversion. The contrast is the chapter’s evidence that a different use of the same era’s tools was possible, not that the tools were kind by default.

Two populations, one renewal era

The citizens’ narrative records a demographic shift that has to be stated carefully. Between 1950 and 1970, it says, the area moved from a majority-white to a majority-nonwhite population as business districts crumbled and the remaining uses were separated. As in Homewood, the racial change and the renewal clearance are overlapping facts, and the overlap is not a cause. African American residents were part of Manchester’s history before the preservation district, which is why the foundation can describe a program for minority families rather than a program that imported a new constituency to admire Victorian porches. The URA study’s clause about African American residents walled off from the riverfront is the spatial result of putting the highway between those residents and the land that was converted to industry. The wall is asphalt and policy. It is not an attribute of the people living east of it.

Who fought is visible in the institutions that still carry the names. The History and Landmarks Foundation, founded into the Liverpool Street threat. The Manchester Citizens Corporation, still the community partner in the foundation’s telling and the sponsor of later reconnection studies. Residents who treated historic housing and neighborhood scale as assets. They did not control the 1959 certification. They did not design Route 65. They organized inside a project area that had already been declared, and they saved a district that the city’s later historic map measures at 51.6 acres and more than 600 resources. Chateau’s families and businesses, more than 700 of them in the authority’s later count, were removed. The chapter will not invent a reason why one block organized in time and another did not, beyond the documented difference in program: a preservation effort concentrated on Manchester’s houses, and a clearance-and-industry plan that the archives locate across the 164 acres and that the highway made permanent on the river side. Agency was real and unequal. The inequality is the point of saying they fought, rather than saying the neighborhood was spared.

What preservation did not give back

Manchester’s survival is easy to sentimentalize into a system that worked. The documents are harsher. The highway remains. The walk score remains low. The connections in and out remain few. The riverfront economic activity the URA study describes sits on the far side of a road that replaced a neighborhood fabric. Preservation saved houses and a grid on the Manchester side. It did not unbuild Route 65, and it did not restore the 700 families and businesses to Chateau. Later planning, including the citizens’ corporation’s reconnection study and the authority’s 2022 district study, is about stitching across the cut: safer east-west movement, a different relationship to the freeway, development that does not treat the wall as eternal. Those studies are admissions that the preservation victory, however real for the brick streets, left a severed geography in place.

There is also a class of loss that designations do not measure. A house restored for a longtime resident is a victory the foundation sought. A house restored and then sold out of the neighborhood a generation later would be a different ending, and this chapter does not have a longitudinal ownership study that would let it declare which ending predominated. The incentive programs are evidence of intention and of a tool. They are not a guarantee printed over every deed from 1979 to the present. What can be said is that Manchester’s organizers named displacement as the enemy of their own success. Chateau’s clearance did not offer that nuance. Removal was the method. Warehouses and the boulevard were the land use. The people who had been the neighborhood were the cost, counted later as more than 700 families and businesses.

Ohio River Boulevard’s extension, which the 1959 project’s archival description names as a purpose of the new street pattern, ties the story to a familiar Pittsburgh bargain. Regional drivers get a faster road. Industrial users get parcels without the old grid. The neighborhood that was in the way gets a historic district if it can organize one, and a warehouse zone if it cannot. The bargain was not secret. Certification, photographs, and a boulevard are public acts. The fight was public too, once Liverpool Street was on a demolition list and a foundation and a citizens’ corporation existed to say no. Between the certification in 1959 and the National Register listing in 1975 there are sixteen years in which the outcome was not yet a plaque. Those years are the fight. The plaque is the record that the fight changed what the city was willing to call valuable.

Almost erased is a claim about power

The title’s “almost” belongs to Manchester, not to Chateau. Chateau’s residential and commercial core, on the sources used here, was not almost removed. It was removed and replaced. Manchester was almost removed in the specific sense that streets such as Liverpool were slated for demolition and then became part of a restoration program instead. “Almost” is not a softening of the regional policy. It is a measurement of how close a demolition schedule came, and of how much organized refusal was required to open a different schedule. Other North Side blocks did not get the same refusal in time. The archives’ 164-acre project area is the reminder that Manchester’s houses and Chateau’s warehouses were inside one certified idea before they were inside two neighborhoods with two reputations.

The people who fought back were not outside the city’s story, looking in. They were residents of a neighborhood the city had annexed in 1907 and then, half a century later, proposed to clear in the name of industry and traffic. Their leverage was local knowledge of the houses, alliances with a new preservation institution, and the unlikely redirection of urban-renewal funds toward repair. Their limit was the highway and the parcels the highway made logical. A honest account gives them the win they actually won: a historic district of more than 600 resources, a program aimed at low- and moderate-income restoration, a grid that still reads as a neighborhood. It does not give them a win they did not win: the reversal of clearance on the river side, or a guarantee that preservation would never become its own pressure on who can afford to stay. The fight changed the possible. It did not abolish the original priority. Route 65 still carries thousands of vehicles a day through the seam where a continuous city fabric used to be.

The houses were the argument

Manchester’s grid is not a backdrop. The city’s historic-preservation description — brick houses, stone trim, wooden porches, an orderly street pattern, 51.6 acres, more than 600 resources — is a inventory of what the demolition schedule was prepared to treat as obsolete. Victorian houses from the second half of the nineteenth century, in the citizens’ narrative, are the same fabric. They were built when the people who owned the riverfront businesses lived in the neighborhood, which is a different social geography from a warehouse district whose workers drive in on Route 65 and leave. Saving the houses was not an aesthetic hobby added after the neighborhood was safe. In 1964, on the foundation’s dating, Liverpool Street and other North Side blocks were already set to come down. The program that answered was a restoration program, aimed at low-income and minority families, using federal, state, and local money, including Title I urban-renewal funds that more often paid for clearance. Turning the usual tool around is the tactical heart of the fight. Residents did not have to invent a new federal statute. They had to insist that the statute’s money could repair a house instead of erasing the lot under it.

Chateau shows the tool in its ordinary direction. The 1959 certification of 164 acres for commercial and industrial sites, with streets revamped to extend Ohio River Boulevard, is the plan before the split in reputation. The authority’s later count of more than 700 families and businesses removed after the highway is the plan’s residential cost on the river side. Warehouses, light industry, shipping, and institutional uses are the land use that replaced them. The highway then made the replacement difficult to walk back, which is why twenty-first-century studies talk about reconnecting across PA-65 rather than about restoring Beaver Avenue as it was. Ferry Street’s demolition, in the citizens’ narrative, removed the commercial spine the streetcars had followed. A neighborhood can lose a spine and keep its houses, or lose both. Manchester, on this record, kept houses and a grid and lost easy movement. Chateau lost the houses and the businesses and gained the industrial parcels the certification had promised.

The racial description in the later studies has to stay descriptive. The citizens’ narrative says the area shifted from majority white to majority nonwhite between 1950 and 1970 as business districts crumbled and uses were separated. The authority’s study says African American residents on the east side of the highway were walled off from the riverfront economy. Those sentences identify who was present and what the road did to their access. They do not identify a people as the reason the road was built. The foundation’s claim that the preservation district was the first in the nation created primarily for African Americans is an institutional claim about who the program served, and this chapter leaves the national superlative in the foundation’s voice. What is solid without the superlative is that minority families were the intended beneficiaries of a restoration strategy, not the targets of a clearance strategy, on the Manchester side of the same era. That is the opposite of ethnic blame. It is a record of who organized and who was supposed to be able to stay.

A win measured against the road that stayed

National Register listing in 1975 and city designation in 1979 are the state’s and the city’s later agreement that the houses were historic. Agreement in 1979 does not rewind 1959. It says that sixteen years of organizing changed the official category of the buildings from renewal obstacle to designated resource. The Manchester Citizens Corporation’s continued role, in the foundation’s account, is the evidence that the fight had a neighborhood institution and not only a preservation nonprofit from outside. Institutions can drift, and a corporation that begins as a residents’ defense can become a manager of grants. This chapter does not have the internal minutes that would let it grade that drift. It has the public sequence: demolition threatened, program built, designations won, highway left in place, later studies devoted to crossing it. The walk score of 45 against Allegheny West’s 73 is a humiliating little number for a flat grid, and it is the right epilogue. Preservation saved the addresses. It did not save the connectivity the addresses once had to the river and to each other across what became the freeway.

Almost erased, then, is not a mood. It is Liverpool Street on a demolition list, a 164-acre certification, and a highway that did erase the Chateau side’s residential and commercial core. The people who fought back are the residents and organizations who turned part of that list into a restoration district of more than 600 resources and who aimed the money at families with low and moderate incomes. They did not fight on equal terms with the agencies that certified the project area and built the road. Their victory is real because the houses are real. It is partial because the road is real, and because more than 700 families and businesses on the Chateau side are counted as removed rather than as restored. Any telling that stops at the brick porches has told the win and skipped the price. Any telling that stops at the warehouses has told the price and skipped the refusal. The chapter exists to keep both.

The archives’ 111 photographs of Redevelopment Area No. 11 are the visual middle of that keeping. A certified project area of 164 acres, dated July 14, 1959, is not a neighborhood memory. It is an official decision that the land straddling today’s Manchester and Chateau would be reorganized for commerce, industry, and a boulevard. Photographs of that kind usually exist to document condition and progress, which means they were made because the city expected the blocks to change. Expectation of change is not the same as a completed erasure, and Manchester’s later historic district is the proof that expectation can be interrupted. Interruption required a foundation formed in 1964 into a demolition threat on Liverpool Street, a citizens’ corporation that outlasted the emergency, and a program that pointed urban-renewal money at repair for families who were supposed to remain. Chateau did not receive the interruption. The highway and the warehouse parcels are what an uninterrupted industrial priority looks like when it is finished. The two outcomes inside one 1959 area are the reason “urban renewal” cannot be used as a synonym for a single fate.

Residents who stayed in the restored streets were not props in a preservation victory. They were the people the program, on the foundation’s description, was built to house: low-income and minority families, longtime residents, owners and tenants the incentives were supposed to protect from the displacement that historic charm can cause. The city designation in 1979 and the National Register listing in 1975 gave those streets a legal status demolition had to reckon with. Status is not a guarantee of affordability in perpetuity, and this chapter has already refused to invent that guarantee. Status is evidence that the fight changed the rules on one side of the highway. On the other side the rules of 1959 ran to their logical end: removal, counted later as more than 700 families and businesses, and a land use of warehouses, shipping, and light industry cut off from the residents who remained east of the road. Pittsburgh almost erased a neighborhood where people organized in time. It erased the residential core where the boulevard and the highway were the point. The difference is the fight, and the fight is what the designations record.

What remains disputed

The foundation’s “first in the nation” claims for a preservation district primarily serving African Americans, and for the use of Title I funds in this way, are stated by the foundation and not re-proven from a national survey in this chapter. The count of more than 700 removed families and businesses is the 2022 authority study’s figure; the 1959 archival description confirms a 164-acre industrial and commercial redevelopment and a boulevard extension without repeating that household total. How many of the 700 were families and how many were businesses is not split in the sentence this chapter uses. Walk scores and traffic volumes describe later conditions. The demographic shift from majority white to majority nonwhite between 1950 and 1970 is the citizens’ narrative’s summary, not a table reproduced here. Whether every anti-displacement incentive succeeded, and what share of restored houses remains with longtime families, is not settled by the designation documents. The moral question of whether industrial reuse of Chateau was worth the removals is a policy argument, not a fact the archives can close. The fact they close is the split outcome: restoration and designation on the Manchester side, clearance and industrial conversion on the Chateau side, and a highway between them.

Evidence Ledger

  • Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, Manchester program account, for the 1964 Liverpool Street threat, the restoration program, and the 1975 and 1979 designations: phlf.org.
  • City of Pittsburgh historic-preservation page, for the district’s 51.6 acres and more than 600 resources: engage.pittsburghpa.gov.
  • Urban Redevelopment Authority, Manchester-Chateau study, January 2022, for the removal of more than 700 families and businesses and the highway’s wall: ura.org TRID study.
  • Pittsburgh City Archives, Redevelopment Area No. 11 photographs, for the July 14, 1959 certification, 164 acres, and the Ohio River Boulevard purpose: pittsburgharchives.access.preservica.com.
  • Manchester Citizens Corporation reconnection narrative, for Route 65, the pre-highway grid, and the preservation fight: manchestercitizens.org.

This chapter is an original public expansion of PittsburghEverything’s Steel City Stories. It does not replace a Google Drive FULL MASTER.

Archival photographs relevant to this chapter. Sourced from Wikimedia Commons with attribution — not modern stock art.

AlleghenyArsenalPowderMagazine

AlleghenyArsenalPowderMagazine

Wikimedia Commons · AlleghenyArsenalPowderMagazine.jpg · Lee Paxton · CC BY-SA 4.0

Streetside in the Deutschtown Historic District

Streetside in the Deutschtown Historic District

Wikimedia Commons · Streetside in the Deutschtown Historic District.jpg · Nyttend · Public domain

Looking NNW on bypassed segment. - Lincoln Highway, Running from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh, Fallsington, Bucks County, PA

Looking NNW on bypassed segment. - Lincoln Highway, Running from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh, Fallsington, Bucks County, PA

Wikimedia Commons · Looking NNW on bypassed segment. - Lincoln Highway, Running from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh, Fallsington, Bucks County, PA HAER PA-592-35.tif · Elliott, Joseph, creator · Public domain

Related Stories