The Neighborhood Pittsburgh Erased for Progress
Preparing the first passage.
Steel City Stories · Chapter 29
The receipt is a deadline, not a rendering of a civic arena. In 1956 the Suriano family, tenants at 1306 Bedford Avenue in the Lower Hill, were given three months to move. Joseph Suriano told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, decades later, that his father walked home from the county elections office for lunch, that the family had no car, and that the boys sold newspapers. They went to Beechview because the streetcar still ran there. They believed St. Peter’s, the Gothic church on Fernando Street, with its school, its convent, its rectory, and its grotto, would be left standing. It was not. By 1959, Suriano said, nobody was there. The sentence he offered for the church, that it would have died anyway with nobody there, is the logic of clearance heard from the inside. Remove the congregation on a schedule, and the building’s later emptiness can be described as natural. The wrecking ball then looks like a consequence rather than a cause.
This chapter stays on that side of the transaction. The long story of Pittsburgh’s Renaissance, the Point, the smoke campaign, Gateway Center, and the corporate rebranding of downtown, is a different chapter in this series. The Lower Hill clearance used the same public redevelopment machinery, and it is not the same story. Here the question is what happened to the people who received the notice, where the records say they went, and which numbers a real archive will support. A tour of famous nightclubs would turn a removal into a scrapbook. The scrapbook is not the relocation.
Ninety-five acres, counted more than once
The City of Pittsburgh Archives describes the Lower Hill Redevelopment Area property inventories, roughly 1953 to 1961, as the Urban Redevelopment Authority’s own file on the land it meant to transfer. The boundary ran by Bigelow Boulevard, Manilla Street, Bedford Avenue, Crawford Street, Pride Street, Fifth Avenue, Sixth Avenue, Wylie Avenue, and Tunnel Street. The finding aid says the area included thousands of buildings on ninety-five acres, surveyed so the authority could carry out a plan that included the Civic Arena. Each surviving record can hold a condition note, a construction date, dimensions, occupancy, a photograph, a deed, and correspondence with the owner. The collection is incomplete. Records for about one hundred fifty parcels are gone. The archivist’s sentence is the right scale for the neighborhood. What remains is a sample of a city that was itemized in order to be purchased.
An early-1960s progress report from the authority, preserved in the same archives’ digital file, puts the Lower Hill in a table that is more precise than a slogan. Ninety-five acres in the project. Ninety-five acres acquired. Nine hundred eighty-nine parcels to be acquired, and nine hundred eighty-nine acquired. Buildings razed: 1,323. Families displaced: 1,551. Families listed as rehoused: 1,551. Business firms relocated: 416. The prose of the same report says all but two of 1,325 structures had been razed. The Civic Arena was complete and operating. The Crosstown Boulevard was under construction from Center Avenue toward Bigelow, with a first connection hoped for in late 1963. Washington Plaza’s Forbes Tower, 396 apartments, was underway. A motor hotel and a center for the arts were still plans, one of them delayed by a lawsuit from downtown hotels. The table is an administrative claim that every displaced family had been rehoused and that 416 firms had been relocated. It is not a claim that the neighborhood had been replaced by the cultural district the brochures had named.
Other public tellings round the same clearance and do not match the table on every cell. The Post-Gazette’s 2018 investigation, using the surviving files and the authority’s relocation story, says that in 1955, when City Council voted the redevelopment, roughly eight thousand people lived among about four hundred businesses. It says the housing authority was to relocate 1,551 families, 29 percent of them into public housing. A Sports and Exhibition Authority summary has described the cleared ground as ninety-five acres, about 1,300 buildings, 413 businesses, and 1,600 families, more than eight thousand people. The differences are real and limited. Buildings cluster around 1,300, or 1,323, or 1,325. Businesses cluster around four hundred, or 413, or 416. Families are 1,551 in the authority’s progress table and the newspaper’s relocation sentence, and about 1,600 in the later arena-authority shorthand. Acreage is ninety-five in the archives and in the table. A 1951 Pittsburgh Press story, quoted by the Post-Gazette, has Mayor David L. Lawrence speaking of one hundred acres to be uprooted. One hundred against ninety-five is a planning number changing before the survey froze. This chapter uses the authority’s table and the archives’ ninety-five acres as the administrative count, and it treats eight thousand residents as the newspaper’s scale for the population, not as a second census conducted here.
Who was counted, and who was moved where
The racial composition is a survey, not a guess. The Post-Gazette reports a 1953 authority survey of 1,885 families then in the Lower Hill: 67.1 percent Black and 32.9 percent white. Average incomes, adjusted by the newspaper into contemporary dollars, were close, on the order of twenty-six thousand for white families and twenty-five thousand for Black families in that conversion. The neighborhood was not a segregated monochrome, and it was not an even split. It was a majority-Black district of families whose earnings, in the survey the paper cites, did not justify a story in which one race was cleared because it was poorer on paper. The Post-Gazette’s reading of the authority’s relocation tracking is the other half of the fact. Most Black families went to the Middle Hill and the Upper Hill, a smaller number to Homewood. Most white families went to Uptown and the South Hills, including Brookline, Beechview, Mount Washington, and Mount Lebanon. The same public project produced two geographies. That is a documented outcome. It is not, by itself, a diary of someone saying they intended the outcome.
Lawrence’s stated reasons are on paper, and they should be quoted as stated reasons. In a 1955 report to Council, as the Post-Gazette renders it, he wrote of the social desirability of complete clearance of the Lower Hill so that it could become an extension of the city’s center, a mighty stride toward Oakland. A 1951 Press headline had already called the area a slum the city would rebuild. Historian Laurence Glasco, interviewed for the newspaper, did not deny that housing in the Lower Hill needed work. He said the period’s reflex was not rehabilitation. It was to wipe the ground clear. He also said many Black leaders supported redevelopment because they had been promised two things they had long asked for: housing for the displaced on the site, and construction jobs for Hill residents. His conclusion is blunt. They received neither. That is a historian’s account of a political bargain, reported by a newspaper. It is evidence of broken public terms. It is not a private memorandum in which an official confesses that race, rather than the stated plan, was the motive. The racial effect can be proved from the survey and the destinations without borrowing a motive the documents do not convict.
The inspection files show how race entered the paperwork anyway. The Post-Gazette quotes an authority note on a building at 91 Washington Place: walls buckling, floors sloping, and, in the inspector’s words, not rentable except to colored. That sentence is a valuation. It treats Black occupancy as a sign of a building’s failure rather than as a tenancy. Other notes describe fire traps, outside toilets, and rooms the inspectors called unfit. Some of those descriptions match photographs of buildings in terrible condition. Others sit beside the newspaper’s finding that many properties were sound, including houses whose condition reports would have supported repair if repair had been the program. The authority, the paper argues, chose the site on the basis of the substandard majority and on the fact that the Lower Hill touched downtown. Landlords, including absentee owners, had been allowed to ignore the code until the code became the reason to buy them out. Clearance punished the tenant for a deterioration the city had not previously treated as urgent. That sequence is an institutional choice. It does not require a secret meeting to be visible.
Leaving, in the words of the people who left
Carlos Peterson’s family moved ahead of the demolition, from Elm Street to a Clay Way tenement and then, when the Lower Hill ran out, toward Rowley Street east of Crawford. He was seven on Clay Way. He told the Post-Gazette that the lights of the Gulf Building reflected on their faces from the roof, and that he could remember jukeboxes and children dancing in doorways. He also said Hill men came to the construction site looking for work and were not hired, and that they salvaged bricks because moving cost money and much was left behind. His memory of sound is enough. It establishes that the streets had a commercial and musical life without turning this chapter into a list of vanished clubs. The list would repeat a litany. The relocation does not need the litany. It needs the fact that a boy watched the street disappear and that the men who lived there were not the men hired to take it down.
Melvin Cherry, who lived on Fernando across from St. Peter’s, described a family of renters moving from Fernando to Webster to Gilmore and then farther up Gilmore, above Logan, staying ahead of the wrecking. He told the paper they were poor and would not get a nicer house, and that his mother kept ten children together. Sanford David, from the Middle Hill, added the people who do not appear in a business census of storefront firms: hucksters, a knife sharpener, a man with a bucket of putty. Cherry added the vegetable sellers and the ice sellers. When a later redevelopment reached a house the David family had owned since 1935, his mother resisted the offer of a better place because ownership was a relationship to a block, not a unit in a relocation table. The authority’s progress report could list 1,551 families rehoused and still miss a woman who experienced rehoused as removed.
Carol Johnson’s family rented on Sachem Way, an alley near Logan that no longer exists. In 1953, before the deadline, her ten-year-old sister Julia was killed, her body left on a playground near the house. Johnson was nine. She told the Post-Gazette that the family did not want to leave, that both parents had grown up in the Hill, and that the house they found in Homewood cost more. Her father drove a truck for a pickle company. Her mother stayed with the children. Years afterward the arena was, for her, the landmark of the sister as well as of the neighborhood. When the arena itself came down, she experienced a second removal, because the building that had replaced the street was still the place she walked in order to remember. A redevelopment narrative that ends at the opening of a civic auditorium has no room for that second grief. A resident narrative has to.
Property owners were not a separate moral class from tenants, and they were not treated by one identical check. Anita Lopatin Smolover watched buildings fall around Tri-State Leather, her family’s business on Fifth Avenue in what is now called Uptown. Her parents had been born in the Lower Hill. Apartments they owned emptied because nobody would rent a building already doomed. She told the paper it broke her husband’s heart, and she connected the loss to first-generation parents who had worked to acquire the buildings. Norma O’Rourke’s family held three grocery stores and houses, including one on Epiphany Street. She remembered Logan Street as stores from Fifth to Bedford. In the mid-1950s the customers and the credit tabs vanished together, and the family went to Brookline. The Post-Gazette also prints the other side of compensation, because the files support it. An owner of six stores with rooms above received $68,200 against an assessed value of $42,655, despite a condition report that called the buildings beyond reclamation. A rooming house at Crawford and Fullerton brought $11,600. The paper’s judgment is that some owners were paid fairly or generously. Payment to an owner is not a new apartment for a tenant, and it is not a congregation for St. Peter’s. The authority could be financially correct in a file and still erase the use of the building.
The notice was the policy
Relocation is a procedure with a file, and the procedure is the part of urban renewal residents actually meet. The authority bought, the housing authority managed occupied buildings until the demolition date, and families were told when their date had come. Suriano’s three months in 1956 is one household’s experience of that calendar. Peterson’s path from Elm to Clay Way to a street east of Crawford is another household staying inside the district until the district ran out. Cherry’s path up Gilmore is the same pattern told as a sequence of addresses. Johnson’s move to a more expensive house in Homewood is the pattern after the Lower Hill would no longer hold her family. These are not anecdotes added for color. They are the only way to see what the progress table’s 1,551 rehoused families meant on a sidewalk. A table can balance displaced and rehoused at the same integer. A family can still be rehoused into a higher rent, a different neighborhood, and a broken parish.
The 29 percent who went into public housing, the figure the Post-Gazette attaches to the 1,551, are a minority of the relocated even on the newspaper’s account. Most families were not placed in a new public project built for them on the cleared ground. They were scattered into existing housing. The destinations, as the paper reads the authority’s tracking, split by race. That split is the fact a later reader is tempted to explain with a motive. The safer and stronger statement uses the documents that exist. A 1953 survey found a district that was two-thirds Black. A relocation record sent most Black families up the Hill or toward Homewood and most white families toward Uptown and the South Hills. An inspector’s note used the word colored as a category of who would accept a failing building. A mayor’s report to Council justified complete clearance as social desirability and as a stride toward Oakland. Glasco adds that support from Black leaders was conditional on replacement housing and jobs, and that the condition was not met. A prosecutor of motives would like a letter that says the stride was a way to move Black residents. The letter in the public record says blight and connection. The map of where people went is still a racial map. Holding both is the chapter’s rule. Effect is proved. A hidden motive is not promoted into a finding because the effect was severe.
Owners, tenants, and the uncounted street economy did not share one compensation. The Post-Gazette’s examples of checks above assessment show that some landlords left with money, including money for buildings the inspectors had called beyond repair. Tenants left with a deadline. David’s memory of the huckster, the knife man, and the putty man, and Cherry’s memory of ice and vegetables, describe a commercial life that a count of 416 relocated firms does not capture. A firm with a lease can be relocated in a table. A man who walks a route cannot. Smolover’s empty apartments, which nobody would rent once the site was doomed, show the transition period itself destroying value before the ball arrived. O’Rourke’s groceries dying of vanished tabs show a business killed by the removal of its customers, which is a different death from a low acquisition price. The authority could report 416 firms relocated and still have presided over a commercial network that failed in place. Relocation of a legal entity is not survival of a trade.
What the cleared ground became, and what it did not
The progress report’s list of projects is the official future as of the early 1960s. An arena in operation. A highway under construction. One apartment tower started. A hotel and a cultural center still prospective. The Post-Gazette’s later summary of the same ground is harsher about the gap. The public program had been sold as a cultural center, an auditorium for the Civic Light Opera, a boulevard, and new private building, at a project scale the paper states as twenty-one million dollars. By the middle of the 1960s a great deal of the acreage was arena, road, a tower, a hotel complex, and surface parking. Demolition had obeyed the schedule. Replacement of a neighborhood economy had not. Glasco’s line about housing and jobs is the resident-side translation of that gap. People were asked to accept erasure as the price of a better Hill. The better Hill, on the cleared acres, did not include them.
The archives finding aid is explicit that the Lower Hill was one piece of a larger renewal program later nicknamed Renaissance I, alongside Gateway Center, an expansion of the Jones and Laughlin works, and the clearing of 254 acres in East Liberty. Naming that kinship is not the same as retelling it. Gateway Center was downtown commercial land and a railroad yard story. East Liberty’s acreage was a different neighborhood’s fight. The Lower Hill’s distinction, for the people in the 1953 survey, was that a majority-Black residential district pressed against downtown was defined as the bridge to Oakland and then removed. Lawrence’s “mighty stride” is a direction. It runs from the central business district toward the universities and hospitals. The neighborhood in between is, in that sentence, the distance to be crossed. Residents experienced the stride as a moving notice, a church coming down, a business losing its tabs, and a relocation that sorted white families toward the South Hills and Black families back up the Hill or toward Homewood.
None of this requires the claim that every house should have stood forever, or that no building in the files was dangerous. Inspectors found structures with no utilities, outside toilets, and walls they said should not remain. Cherry’s family did not describe Fernando Street as comfortable. The investigative question is who had the authority to decide that the answer to a bad house was the removal of a whole district, who was told the removal would return as housing and wages, and who absorbed the years in which the ground was a job site and then a parking lot. The authority’s table says 1,551 families were rehoused. The people the Post-Gazette found say rehoused meant Beechview, Homewood, a more expensive rent, a street that no longer existed, and an arena that stood where the grocery and the grotto had been. Both statements fit inside one project. They do not describe the same experience of it.
The neighborhood Pittsburgh erased for progress was erased with a file number on each parcel, a racial survey that was allowed to remain a statistic, and a relocation pattern that separated the statistic into two maps. Progress, in the mayor’s report, was clearance and a connection to Oakland. Progress, in the progress report, was an arena and a count of families processed. Progress, on Bedford Avenue, was three months to get out and a church that did not survive the absence of its people. The private motive behind that sequence is not a fact this chapter can see. The public record is. A redevelopment authority created under the state urban redevelopment law, governed by a board the mayor chaired, bought a ninety-five-acre district, razed more than thirteen hundred buildings, moved more than fifteen hundred families, and relocated about four hundred businesses. Most of the families in the pre-clearance survey were Black. Most Black families and most white families did not end up in the same places. The ground they left did not become the neighborhood they had been promised. That is the erasure. It is documented. It does not need to be psychologized to be understood.
The Lower Hill’s afterlife as an arena and a parking plateau is the visible remainder, and it is not the whole remainder. Families who moved up the Hill stayed in the city and in the path of later projects. Families who moved to Homewood entered a neighborhood that would spend later decades fighting disinvestment this book tells elsewhere. Families who reached Beechview, Brookline, or Mount Lebanon entered the streetcar suburbs with whatever the acquisition and the new rent allowed. The Civic Arena, completed and operating in the authority’s early-1960s report, gave the cleared ground a postcard. It did not give Sachem Way back, or St. Peter’s, or the grocery tabs on Logan Street. A postcard is what a city shows when the parcel files have done their work. The files, incomplete as the archives admit, are still the more honest monument. They itemize a neighborhood in order to end it, and they leave the racial survey and the divergent destinations sitting in the record beside the mayor’s language of a stride.
Evidence Ledger
- Pittsburgh City Archives, Lower Hill Redevelopment Area Property Inventories, circa 1953–1961. Ninety-five acres, the street boundary, thousands of buildings, the Civic Arena plan, and the incomplete survival of the parcel files.
- Urban Redevelopment Authority progress report, City Archives digital file. The Lower Hill line of the progress table: 95 acres, 989 parcels, 1,323 buildings razed, 1,551 families displaced and listed as rehoused, 416 business firms relocated, and the narrative that 1,325 structures had been razed for the arena, the Crosstown Boulevard, and unfinished private projects.
- Diana Nelson Jones, “Traces of a Lost Neighborhood,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, June 18, 2018. The Suriano, Peterson, Cherry, David, Johnson, Smolover, and O’Rourke accounts; the 1953 survey of 1,885 families, 67.1 percent Black and 32.9 percent white; the relocation directions; Lawrence’s 1955 language of complete clearance; Glasco’s account of promised housing and jobs; the inspector’s racial note; and the figures of roughly eight thousand people, about four hundred businesses, and 1,551 families with 29 percent to public housing.
- Pittsburgh Sports and Exhibition Authority, Lower Hill redevelopment summary. A later public rounding: 95 acres, about 1,300 buildings, 413 businesses, and 1,600 families, more than eight thousand people. Used as a comparison with the authority table, not as a replacement for it.
What remains disputed
The counts disagree at the margin and agree on the order of magnitude. Acreage is ninety-five in the archives and the progress table, and one hundred in Lawrence’s 1951 remark as the Post-Gazette quotes the Press. Buildings are 1,323 razed in the table, 1,325 in the report’s prose, about 1,300 in the Sports and Exhibition Authority’s later summary. Businesses are 416 relocated in the table, about four hundred in the newspaper, 413 in the arena authority’s summary. Families are 1,551 in the table and in the Post-Gazette’s housing-authority sentence, and about 1,600 in the later summary. The survey of 1,885 families in 1953 is not the same base as the 1,551 relocated later. Population “roughly eight thousand” is the newspaper’s scale. This chapter does not possess a door-to-door census of its own. Compensation is disputed in interpretation. The Post-Gazette finds some owners paid above assessment. Tenants and parishioners received a different currency, which was time to leave. Whether Black leaders “signed on” is Glasco’s historical judgment, reported in the interview, not a vote count reproduced here. The racial outcome of relocation is sourced to the authority’s tracking as the newspaper describes it. A private, unspoken motive for choosing the Lower Hill because its residents were Black is not established by that outcome. The stated motives on the mayoral page are blight, complete clearance, and a connection from downtown toward Oakland. Those motives were public, they were racial in effect, and they are not the same thing as a confession.
This is an original public expansion of the short website chapter. It does not replace the Google Drive FULL MASTER.
Historic Pittsburgh · Chapter 29
Archival photographs relevant to this chapter. Sourced from Wikimedia Commons with attribution — not modern stock art.

US Housing Authority in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Site PA-1-2: the before photo
Wikimedia Commons · US Housing Authority in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Site PA-1-2, the before photo - NARA - 196099.tif · Unknown authorUnknown author or not provided · Public domain

MELLON SQUARE IN DOWNTOWN PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA. IT WAS REFURBISHED DURING URBAN RENEWAL IN THE RENAISSANCE PROGRAM OF THE EARLY 1950'S AND HAS CREATED A PARK-LIKE ATMOSPHERE IN THE CITY
Wikimedia Commons · MELLON SQUARE IN DOWNTOWN PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA. IT WAS REFURBISHED DURING URBAN RENEWAL IN THE RENAISSANCE... - NARA - 557256.jpg · John L. Alexandrowicz · Public domain

Pittsburgh-pennsylvania-mellon-arena-2007
Wikimedia Commons · Pittsburgh-pennsylvania-mellon-arena-2007.jpg · Derek Jensen (Tysto) · Public domain
Related Stories

The Week Pittsburgh’s Grief Became Fire
After Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in April 1968, grief, anger, unrest and a later peace march transformed Pittsburgh’s Hill District in different ways across the same week.

The Neighborhood Pittsburgh Almost Erased—and the People Who Fought Back
Manchester and Chateau show two sides of urban renewal: clearance and industrial conversion on one side, preservation and resident organizing on the other.