Skip to main content
Back to Steel City Stories
The Strike That Turned McKees Rocks Into a Battlefield — Steel City Stories
HistoryChapter 25 of 4118 min read

The Strike That Turned McKees Rocks Into a Battlefield

Steel City Stories

Preparing the first passage.

Steel City Stories · Chapter 25

This chapter is not about Donora. Donora is a Monongahela mill town, and its disaster belongs to 1948. The strike that turned a workplace into a battlefield in the summer of 1909 happened on the Ohio, at McKees Rocks and the adjoining works settlement of Schoenville, inside the Pressed Steel Car Company plant. The receipt is a pay system. Historian John N. Ingham, in a 1971 article in Pennsylvania History, describes how Frank N. Hoffstot, who with a partner had taken control of a firm built in 1899 out of the Fox and Schoen car companies, extended a track, or early assembly-line, method of building railroad cars and then changed how the men on that track were paid. By 1909 the pooling system meant that a gang’s wages were held in common and could be pulled down by the slowest position on the line. The immigrants who did the unskilled and semiskilled work were the people the pool hit. They were also the people who walked out.

Ingham’s geography is specific, and it keeps the story out of the wrong valley. McKees Rocks already had a split map. Immigrants lived chiefly in the Bottoms along the Ohio and in Presston, the company town pressed against the river. Native-born workers lived on higher ground or across the river on Pittsburgh’s North Side. Social contact between those groups was thin. The plant employed a large skilled minority and, in his estimate, about thirty-five hundred semiskilled and unskilled immigrants who made up the labor pool. Pressed Steel was not a sideshow to Homestead. It was a later generation of the same regional fact. A Pittsburgh-district manufacturer had organized production so that speed was a collective number, and then had organized pay so that the men who could least afford a lost day carried the risk when the line slowed.

The morning the committee was refused

On Monday evening, July 12, 1909, employees met to discuss the pool and decided to take their grievances to the plant office. The next morning the company refused to hear the committee. Ingham, citing the Pittsburgh press, writes that nearly every employee quit, beginning with six hundred men in the riveting department, and that the walkout was effectively on by midmorning. About five hundred stayed. They were skilled native-born workers in the wooden-car department, the men least touched by the pool. The division inside the works was visible before any organizer from out of town arrived. It was a division between a payment method and the men who could ignore it.

That night the strikers met at Turner Hall. Police broke the meeting up. The strikers marched through the night and by morning had stationed themselves at O’Donovan’s Bridge, the link toward the North Side, where they could meet people heading for the plant. The strike’s first geography was a bridge and a gate, not a doctrine. Hoffstot answered in the newspapers. On July 17 he said the company would receive no committee, that there would be no arbitration, that unhappy men were not wanted, and that the pooling system would not be changed and would in fact be extended. A few days later the Pittsburgh Leader quoted the line that stuck to him: it was nobody’s business how he ran his affairs. The Gazette Times, which was not a labor paper, called the attitude one that would not recommend itself to the public. For a short period the stubbornness of the office did what the strikers’ own arguments had not fully done. It moved respectable opinion toward men the same papers had been ready to dismiss as foreigners.

The grievances were more than a slogan about wages. Ingham lists the demands that accumulated around the pool. Men wanted the pool abolished and pay by the hour, the day, or the piece, so that one slow station did not confiscate a whole gang’s week. They wanted an end to abuses in company housing and in the way fines and rents could follow a paycheck. A workforce that did not share a language still shared a pay envelope that could not be audited from the floor. The pool was efficient for a manager who needed the line to move. It was opaque for a riveter who could not tell whether Saturday’s shortage was his work, his partner’s work, or the company’s arithmetic. That opacity is why a strike of immigrants is not a story about exotic tempers. It is a story about a document the worker was not allowed to read.

Two leaderships, one plant

The strike immediately produced rival authorities. Native-born skilled men, organized around figures such as C. A. Wise and a group Ingham calls the Big Six, wanted a settlement that would restore work without handing the plant to a radical union. The immigrant strikers, who had started the walkout, distrusted a bargain struck by men the pool had spared. Ingham prints the early foreign grievance committee as the press recorded the names, a list that runs through Anthony Paviciek Vuk, Wandel Pajlovits, Anthony Derzick, Dave Dakatch, Tony Olenick, Joe Smith, Nick Signorelli, Georg Vassos, and others. The names are the chapter’s correction to any story in which “the strikers” are a single English-speaking subject. They are also a warning about spelling. Newspapers mangled them. The mangling is evidence of distance, not a reason to pretend the committee was anonymous.

The Industrial Workers of the World entered that gap. William E. Trautmann, one of the IWW’s founders, was in the district by the middle of August. Ingham dates a turn toward the IWW’s leadership to about August 16 and August 17. The IWW’s practical program, as he describes it, was to stop the strikebreakers and force the company onto the immigrants’ terms. After Trautmann’s later arrest, other IWW figures, including men the national memory of the strike remembers as Joe Ettor and William Haywood, became part of the public story. Ingham is more interested in function than in celebrity. The IWW gave a multilingual strike a militant strategy at the moment Pearl Bergoff, the professional strikebreaker, was pouring replacement workers into the plant. It also gave newspapers a word, socialist, that they could wave without learning the organization. Ingham’s judgment is that the IWW was blamed for the disorder before most editors understood it as a political union at all. Eugene V. Debs, the socialist, could still be praised when he stood at Indian Mound and told the strikers to refuse violence. The distinction matters. Local opinion could admire an appeal for calm from a famous radical and, in the same week, treat the IWW as the author of every shot. The scapegoat and the organizer were not the same analytical category, even when they occupied the same meeting ground.

August 22, and the toll that will not sit still

Violence, in Ingham’s chronology, begins in earnest on August 17, after the IWW assumed leadership, as a response to Bergoff’s strikebreakers. It reaches what he calls the riot stage on Sunday, August 22, in a series of gun battles between strikers and police. His score sheet for that day, drawn from the Leader of August 23, the National Labor Tribune of August 26, and the Gazette Times of August 22, is six dead, six dying, and forty to fifty injured. He is careful enough to call it a score sheet from the day, not a completed coroner’s roll. The phrase “six dying” means the Monday papers were looking at men who might yet become part of the dead. Any later total that treats August 22 as a closed integer is already ahead of the sources Ingham trusted.

Two of the dead can be named from the Pennsylvania State Police’s own memorials, which is a different kind of document from a newspaper’s overnight list. Private John L. Williams, Troop A, was killed on August 22, 1909, when he and four other troopers were attacked at O’Donovan’s Bridge in Schoenville while going to the Pressed Steel plant. Private Jack Curtis Smith was shot in both legs and suffered a fractured skull in that same attack. He died the next day, August 23, at Mercy Hospital in Pittsburgh. Superintendent John C. Groome’s General Order No. 31, issued September 8, mourned both men as killed in the line of duty at McKees Rocks on the night of August 22 and said their bodies were looted of cash and other possessions. The memorials also name the wounded troopers with them: Lucian Jones, George Kitch, and Patrick O’Donnell. The state police, in other words, can document two of their own dead and three seriously hurt. They do not thereby document the whole Sunday.

Later summaries widen the number and do not agree with each other. This chapter will not adopt a strike-long total from a reference compilation. A later page can offer twelve, sixteen, or twenty-six and still not be Ingham’s next-morning count or the state police’s named dead. Those are different frames, and this chapter has not opened the studies that would justify picking one. One frame is a next-morning newspaper tally that still had men “dying.” One is the state police’s named loss. A strike-long estimate that pulls in deaths before and after that Sunday would be a third frame, and it is not a finding here. This chapter will say what can be anchored. On August 22 and into August 23, state troopers Williams and Smith were killed after an attack at O’Donovan’s Bridge. Contemporary Pittsburgh papers, as used by Ingham, counted six dead and six dying that day, with forty to fifty injured. A single agreed death toll for the McKees Rocks strike does not exist in the sources read here, and inventing one would hide the disagreement the newspapers already admitted by leaving six men in the dying column.

The power that followed the shooting

The Sunday fight changed the politics even where it did not settle the number. Ingham writes that a press which had swung toward the strikers after Hoffstot’s refusals swung back after the gunfire. The Leader, which had championed them, condemned the rioting. Thirty more state troopers were sent. What the papers called virtual martial law followed. On August 25 troopers began searching the houses of foreign residents under a January 1909 law that barred aliens from keeping deadly weapons at home. Guns and knives were taken from immigrant households. Americans, Ingham notes from the Leader, were allowed to keep theirs. The search was a constitutional fact as well as a tactical one. The same Commonwealth that could not produce a neutral pay audit could produce a house-to-house disarming that followed citizenship. Immigrant strikers lost the weapons and, with them, a share of the capacity to bargain in the street. The Big Six gained relative power without winning an argument about the pool.

The company was losing a different argument at the same time. On August 21 Albert Vamos, a Bergoff strikebreaker, got out of the plant and told Edgar L. G. Prochnick, the Austro-Hungarian vice-consul in Pittsburgh, that he had been held against his will. With William McNair, attorney for the Big Six, they swore peonage affidavits against Hoffstot and against Samuel Cohen, described as Bergoff’s lieutenant, before United States Commissioner W. T. Lindsay. The allegation, later aired in 1911 congressional hearings titled “Peonage in Western Pennsylvania,” was that men had been recruited under false promises, underfed, underpaid, and threatened when they tried to leave. Federal district attorney John H. Jordan, a Department of Labor examiner, the Ellis Island immigration service, Allegheny County district attorney William A. Blakeley, and finally United States Commissioner of Labor Charles P. Neill all touched the inquiry. Ingham does not ask the reader to treat every affidavit as a conviction. He shows the political effect. Hoffstot’s plant, which had been able to say that its affairs were nobody’s business, was now the subject of a federal labor investigation and a consul’s complaint. The strikers had been discredited by August 22. The company was discredited by the testimony of men it had imported to break the strike. The Big Six, tainted by neither the IWW nor the peonage affidavits, became the available negotiators.

A settlement that was not recognition

Secret talks followed. On September 7 Neill met plant manager James Rider and then Wise. The company moved. Wise took a proposal back to Indian Mound: no Sunday work, half days on Saturday, no return to the 1907 wage scale immediately, but a promised increase of ten to fifteen percent within sixty to ninety days. There would be no signed agreement recognizing the strikers as an organization. Rehiring would be individual. Ignaz Klawier of the IWW, in Ingham’s account, begged the crowd not to take it. On September 8 the offer was voted. Only 2,511 strikers cast ballots, and twelve of those ballots were no. The Big Six and the chamber of commerce investigated each voter before he was allowed to vote, a procedure that makes the landslide less simple than a ratio. By September 10 about forty-five hundred men were reported back. About fifteen hundred foreign strikers, including original leaders, had not been taken back. They voted to continue, with the IWW beside them. Wise then had the sheriff demand Trautmann’s charter. The second strike, Ingham writes, ended on the morning of Friday, September 17.

What the men won can be stated without romance. The pool was the issue that started the walkout, and the settlement altered hours and promised a near-term percentage increase. What they did not win was a signed union in a plant that had just learned it could rehire one by one. Hoffstot’s July statement that there would be no arbitration was not fully sustained. His deeper claim, that the company would decide who had a job, was sustained by the individual-rehiring clause and by the exclusion of the fifteen hundred. The IWW had made the strike national and had helped force the company to the table by making strikebreakers a scandal. It left McKees Rocks without the organization it had offered. Ingham’s closing judgment is chilly and useful. Native-born progressives and skilled workers could prefer a settlement that restored the pre-strike order, ended the shooting, and cut the IWW off from the foreign workforce. The immigrant strikers who stayed out discovered that a battlefield victory is not the same thing as a contract.

Why this is not Homestead, and not a riot story

Seventeen years separated the Homestead barges from O’Donovan’s Bridge, and the difference is the point of telling them as separate chapters. Homestead was a craft union of skilled steelmen confronting the most famous manager in the industry, with a detective agency hired in advance and a militia sent by the governor after the battle. McKees Rocks was a car plant whose decisive grievance was a pooling formula, whose first strikers were immigrant production workers, and whose most lethal public force was the new state constabulary rather than a rented Pinkerton landing. The IWW’s presence tempts a later reader to file 1909 as a preface to national radicalism. Ingham’s article resists that filing. He shows a local pay fight that became radical when the company refused a committee and imported a professional strikebreaking firm, and that then became a public-order crisis the newspapers could understand more easily than they could understand the pool.

The track system is worth slowing down, because the pool is otherwise just a word. Ingham describes electric cranes lifting car frames along a line of roughly a dozen positions, each gang performing one step, a finished car leaving the far end. Straight piece rates had earlier raised weekly earnings and quieted the floor. The pool was Hoffstot’s answer to a weakness in that success. If one gang lagged, the whole line lagged, and men on piece rates lost time they could not control. Pooling tied the gang’s pay together so that the slow position became everyone’s loss. It was a managerial solution to interdependence, and it concentrated the pain on the immigrant majority who occupied the unskilled stations. Skilled native-born men in the wood department, paid by the day, could watch the walkout from inside the gate. Their distance from the pool is why a strike that looked, from Pittsburgh, like an ethnic eruption was, from the rivet line, a dispute about arithmetic.

Presston and the Bottoms made the arithmetic into a landscape. Company housing meant a lost job could become a lost room. Ingham notes threats of eviction against families who would not return, including a public warning that hundreds more families would be put out. A striker who lived in a company town was negotiating with his landlord and his employer at the same desk. That is a different leverage from Homestead, where the union had a town government, a burgess, and a building of its own. At McKees Rocks the immigrant meeting places were Turner Hall, until the police closed it, and Indian Mound, where the strike held its open assemblies. The mound was not a romantic symbol. It was where Debs could be heard pleading against violence and where, weeks later, Wise could count a ballot the company was willing to live with. Geography kept the factions visible. The North Side and the higher streets held the native-born skilled men. The river held the pool.

Bergoff’s operation supplied the other half of the August crisis. A strikebreaker firm is a business with recruiters, guards the strikers called nobles, and a compound that can be locked from the inside. The Vamos affidavit, whatever a court might later have done with it, described that compound to a consul and a United States commissioner: false pretenses, bad food, less pay than promised, and threats at the moment of exit. Congressional hearings in 1911 preserved the testimony at length. The political importance in August 1909 was speed. A company that would not receive its own employees’ committee was suddenly receiving federal questions about whether it was holding other men’s employees as peons. Neill’s arrival on September 7 did not make the United States a friend of the IWW. It made indefinite refusal expensive. Hoffstot could still deny a signature. He could no longer pretend the plant was a private room.

The alien-weapons searches of August 25 deserve to be remembered beside that federal pressure, because they show which public power was fast. A statute written in January 1909, months before the strike, made it illegal for aliens to keep deadly weapons at home. Applied after the August 22 gunfire, it authorized troopers to enter immigrant houses, take guns and knives, and leave citizen households armed. Ingham’s source is the Leader. The asymmetry does not require a theory of anyone’s secret motives. It was written on the face of the enforcement. The same state that mourned Williams and Smith, rightly, as men killed on a bridge, used the days after their deaths to disarm one part of the town by nationality. A strike about a pay pool had become a question of who was allowed to be armed in his own kitchen. That is the battlefield the title names. It was not a fog, and it was not Donora. It was an Ohio River car plant in which immigrant workers forced a company to bargain, the state police enforced the boundary of the bargain with rifles and searches, and the paper that ended the main strike refused to recognize the men as a union.

Indian Mound is where the strike’s last public arithmetic happened, and the arithmetic is less tidy than a victory paragraph. Ingham records 2,511 ballots on September 8 and twelve negative votes, after representatives of the Big Six and the chamber of commerce examined each man before he could vote. A landslide inside a screened electorate is a political result. It is also a procedure. About fifteen hundred of the foreign strikers, including men who had led the walkout, were not back at work by September 10 and voted to keep striking. The second strike’s end on the morning of September 17 closed that remainder without the signature Hoffstot had refused in July. Hours changed. A percentage was promised on a delay of sixty to ninety days. The pool, which had started as a manager’s solution to an interdependent line, was no longer something the company could refuse even to discuss. It was also no longer the basis of a union the company had to recognize. Those are the terms a reader can defend from Ingham without inflating them into a transformation of American labor law.

The state police memorials and the peonage hearings belong in the same paragraph because they are the two arms of public power in this strike. One arm killed and was killed at a bridge, then searched immigrant houses under an alien-weapons statute. The other arm, slower, put a company president and a strikebreaker lieutenant under a federal accusation of holding workers as peons. McKees Rocks in 1909 is the story of an industrial workplace that had no legitimate payroll language for its immigrant majority, and of a government that answered first with the constabulary. The IWW did not invent the pool, the bridge, or the company town. It arrived because those facts had already split the workforce into people who could wait for Wise and people who could not. Remembering the strike as a riot in a foreign colony erases the pay system. Remembering it as a clean IWW triumph erases the September vote, the twelve dissenters inside a managed ballot, and the fifteen hundred who were not taken back. The battlefield was real. The institution that survived it was the company’s right to hire without a signature.

McKees Rocks remains a Pittsburgh story because the city that bought the railroad cars, read the Gazette Times, and sent the constabulary was the same city that had watched Homestead. The distance between the two fights is the distance between a skilled lodge that lost a mill to the militia and an immigrant production workforce that lost a signature and kept a scar. Pressed Steel’s cars moved on the railroads that carried Pittsburgh’s freight. The men who riveted them lived in a company town on the Ohio, inside Allegheny County, close enough that a consul, a federal attorney, and a United States commissioner of labor could all reach the gate in a month. The battlefield was local. The audience was the district. Forgetting the pool and remembering only the troopers reverses the order of the facts. The troopers came because the pool had already produced a strike the company preferred to break.

Evidence Ledger

What remains disputed

The death toll is the central dispute, and it should stay open. Ingham’s newspapers on and just after August 22 said six dead, six dying, and forty to fifty injured. The state police can name Williams and Smith. They cannot, on the memorial pages, name every striker, deputy, or strikebreaker killed in the wider strike. Later reference works gather those deaths into ranges of twelve to twenty-six and sometimes isolate a figure of sixteen for the worst day. None of those ranges was re-audited here against a single coroner’s docket. Hoffstot’s quotations are taken from Ingham’s citations to the Leader and the Gazette Times, not from a press-release file. The peonage case is a hearing record and a set of affidavits. It is not, in the material used here, a reported criminal conviction of Hoffstot. How fully the pool was abolished, as against merely softened by an hours rule and a promised percentage, depends on which clause of the September settlement a reader treats as the real contract. The company refused a signature. That refusal is not disputed. The size of the violence is.

This is an original public expansion of the short website chapter. It does not replace the Google Drive FULL MASTER.

Archival photographs relevant to this chapter. Sourced from Wikimedia Commons with attribution — not modern stock art.

McKeesRocksBridgePA

McKeesRocksBridgePA

Wikimedia Commons · McKeesRocksBridgePA.jpg · Lee Paxton · CC BY-SA 4.0

Typical Mill workers at lunch, Pittsburgh, Pa

Typical Mill workers at lunch, Pittsburgh, Pa

Wikimedia Commons · Typical Mill workers at lunch, Pittsburgh, Pa.jpg · The Metropolitan News Co., Manufacturers of Souvenir Postal Cards, Boston, Mass & Germany. · Public domain

St. Mary’s Church, McKees Rocks, 2015-08-27, 01

St. Mary’s Church, McKees Rocks, 2015-08-27, 01

Wikimedia Commons · St. Mary’s Church, McKees Rocks, 2015-08-27, 01.jpg · Cbaile19 · CC0

Related Stories